Fall 2003
Prof. Deirdre Golash
Class hours: W 2:10-4:50 pm
Office hours: M 8-9 pm, Tu 2-5 pm, W 5-7 pm
Office: Ward 252
Phone: 885-2955 (Call any time; you may leave a message if I am not in.)
E-mail: dgolash@american.edu (for prompt response please include "JLS 501 in subject line)Course Description
This course examines leading philosophical theories of justice, particularly with respect to the foundations for the authority of the state, the justification of property rights, and the distribution of wealth in society. Liberal, Marxist, libertarian, communitarian, and feminist views are considered.
Materials:
All listed materials are required. Most are available on 2-hour reserve at the library. Links to web versions are provided where available.
Requirements
- John Locke, Second Treatise of Government, Prometheus Books.
- J.S. Mill, Utilitarianism, Broadview Press.
- John Rawls, A Theory of Justice, Harvard University Press, 1971.
- Robert Nozick, Anarchy, State, and Utopia, Basic Books, 1974.
- Susan Okin, Justice, Gender and the Family. Basic Books, 1989.
- Additional materials on web and electronic databases
Grading
- All students are expected to read the assigned materials carefully and to come to class prepared to discuss them.
- Each student will write a 10-15 page paper on a topic to be selected before the midterm date. You will choose your own specific dates to submit a topic and draft paper. These dates are binding once selected.
- There will be an optional midterm and a required final exam.
- Class attendance and participation - 10%
- Tests - 40% (if you take the midterm, each test counts 20%)
- Draft paper - 15%
- Final Paper - 35%
| TENTATIVE SCHEDULE
Changes in content and scheduling are likely, depending on the pace of discussion and the interests of the group. Changes will be announced in class. |
||
| Aug. 27 | Introduction | Forward
your AU email to an address that you check regularly Check your Blackboard access |
| Sept. 3 |
Locke, Second
Treatise of Government, Ch. 2-5, 8-9 Nozick on Locke (property) - pp. 174-182 |
Paper due date selection |
| Sunday,
Sept. 7 |
DJLS Barbecue |
|
| Sept. 10 |
Mill, Utilitarianism Rawls on Utilitarianism - Ch. 1, sec. 5 Nozick on side constraints - pp. 26-35 |
|
| Sept. 17 |
Marx, Estranged
Labour; The
Power of Money; Wage-Labour
and Capital [Study
Guide] Nozick on Marx, pp. 246-250 |
|
| Sept. 24 |
Rawls,
sections 3, 4, 11, 17, 26; p. 266 (statement of two principles of
justice at end of section 39). (32 pages) |
|
| Oct. 1 |
Rawls, sections 32, 33, 36, 52, 80, 81
(33 pages) Okin on Rawls, Justice, Gender, and the Family, pp. 89-110 (ch. 5) |
|
| Oct. 8 |
Nozick,
pp. 149-164; 183-204 Okin on Nozick, Justice, Gender, and the Family, pp. 74-89 (ch. 4) |
Test your Lexis-Nexis access |
| Oct. 15 |
Isaiah
Berlin, Two Concepts of Liberty G.A. Cohen, The Structure of Proletarian Unfreedom, Phil osophy and Public Affairs 12:3-33 (1983) (JSTOR) Waldron, Homelessness and the issue of freedom, UCLA Law Rev. 1991 (Lexis-Nexis) |
Optional take-home midterm To get the Waldron article: Go to Lexis-Nexis, click on "Legal Research." Type "homelessness" in the first field and "waldron" in the second. Put in dates "1991" to "1991." This search yields two articles, one of which is Waldron's. |
| Oct. 22 | Sandel, The
Procedural Republic and the
Unencumbered Self, Political
Theory 12:81-96 (1984) Alisdair MacIntyre, The Privatization of Good, Review of Politics 52, 1990:320-48. Okin on MacIntyre, Justice, Gender, and the Family, pp. 41-74 (ch. 3) |
Midterm due Last date for topic selection Copies of MacIntyre article available from outside my office, Ward 252. |
| Oct. 29 |
Okin, Justice, Gender and the Family,
Chs. 1, 2, 7, 8 Sommers, Philosophers Against the Family [handout] |
|
| Nov. 5 |
Williams, The Idea of Equality
[handout] Nozick on Williams, Anarchy, State and Utopia pp. 232-238 Hayek, The mirage of social justice [handout] |
|
| Nov. 12 |
Levy, Liberal
Equality and Inherited
Wealth, Political Theory 11:547 (1983) Charles Murray, A Proposal for Public Welfare [handout] |
|
| Nov. 19 |
NO CLASS (office hours will
be held Monday the 17th) |
|
| Nov. 26 |
NO CLASS - Thanksgiving (office hours will be held Monday and Tuesday, Nov. 24-25) | |
| Dec. 3 |
Barry, Humanity and
justice in global perspective (Nomos XXIV) Hardin, The Case Against Helping the Poor |
FINAL PAPERS DUE |
| Dec. 10 |
Study day - Review Class (optional) |
|
| Dec. 15, 5:30 |
Optional early exam Ward 204 |
|
| Dec. 17 |
Final exam |
|