Responsible Behavior: Possibly a Good Idea

I taught an entry-level math course in the fall of 2010. Although I had no attendance policy, most students attended regularly (not perfectly, but regularly) throughout the semester. A significant minority had spotty attendance for at least part of the semester, and often only a small part. Take a look at the grade distribution for the class:

Grade distribution, Elementary Math Modeling, Fall, 2010

Suggestive, no?

The following semester, I taught a slightly higher-level class. Again, I had no attendance policy, but I explained what had happened the previous semester, and showed a version of the chart above. Success! The vast majority attended class regularly throughout the semester. On the other hand, a significant minority skipped at least a quarter of the homework assignments. (Homework scores formed a significant, but not overwhelming, part of overall grades.)

Grade distribution, Calculus 1, Spring, 2011

I guess that the lesson here is to be responsible in at least two ways. While my previous teaching experience shows that this is not a guarantee of success, the charts above suggest that responsibility might not be too bad of an idea.